Dries Maes, Estelle Petitclerc, Fanny Vanrykel, Xavier Defoy, Marc Bourgeois, and Bart Peeters (2016)
Policy combinations to navigate between private and public monopolies in emerging technological sectors
In: Global Conference on Environmental Taxation - Smart Instrument Mixes in a Greening Economy.
Finance is one of the main critical issues for the development of a low carbon society especially during 
times of economic recession. Closing this green investment gap will require policy intervention. This paper 
is part of a larger research project – the ALPI project – which aims at analysing and designing relevant 
instruments  to  accelerate  the  transition  towards  a  low  carbon  society.  As  a  showcase  of  emerging 
technologies in Belgium, the Hasselt University, the University of Liège and the Geological Survey of 
Belgium are investigating the regional potential for geothermal electricity production. Deep geothermal 
energy appears to be currently on the edge of a take-off. But the actual emergence of this technology 
is subject to developments in legislation and incentives from regional governments. Different risk/return 
expectations  across  stages  of  the  investment  continuum  exist  and  the  financial  structures  that  are 
employed at each stage may require different types of public support. 
Considering the particularities of the development of geothermal energy in Belgium, we present different 
combinations  of  incentives  to  support  geothermal  energy,  and  we  review  different  sector  evolutions 
through  a  broad  stakeholder  consultation  (policy  makers,  sector  federations,  industry,  researchers, 
banking sector, investors, etc.). However, a reviewof the learning effects shows that neither of the two 
combinations can prevent a regional monopolisation of the underground as a natural resource either by 
a private first-mover, or a public investor. Therefore, intermediary solutions are proposed to providea 
balance between the two extremes, and to ensure an  improved sector growth and a continuous open 
market. 
Keywords: Technological innovation, Policy instruments, Competition, Combination of policies 
            Abstract of an Oral Presentation or a Poster
            Document Actions

